| Quote from an 8-year-old child |
[Jan. 13th, 2008|08:16 am] |
| [ | Current Mood |
| | Philosophical | ] | "My mother says, we shouldn't watch any videos, because even if we watch a video that isn't bad, maybe later we'll watch a video that is bad."
*feels self to have been remarkably restrained in not saying, "I think your mother is making a very foolish decision."*
Way to not teach your children how to make judgements.
It seems to me rather like God telling Adam, don't eat from the tree, and Adam telling Eve, don't touch the tree. When Eve touched it inadvertently, she assumed she was already as bad as she could be, so she ate from it too. If this kid, at some point in her life, sees an episode of Sesame Street or a Charlie Chaplin movie, she's going to figure she's totally off the derech and watch Beavis and Butthead, Knocked Up, whatever inappropriate films there are out there.
You could replace 'videos' with almost anything. I once offered to bring these kids to the library, and their mother mentioned quietly that she doesn't let them go to the library, because there are books there she doesn't approve of. O...kay.
Way to not teach your children how to make judgements.
But how about replacing it with 'people'? There are unpleasant people in the world; perhaps one should not speak to any people, because even if you first speak to nice people you might end up speaking to not-nice people! I have yet to hear anyone espouse that particular view, thank heavens.
At the same time as being horrified by the restrictions placed on children in this community, I'm impressed with the courage of the parents in letting their children be exposed to me. Here I am, the girl with a BA, who *gasp* DATED her husband before getting engaged, who met him *double gasp* independently, who *triple gasp* watches TV and movies, AND reads BOOKS!, judging for herself which ones are appropriate and which ones are not, and even more so, HAS INTERNET!!! The horror! And yet the people here are very friendly, and my neighbors seem to have no problem in theory or in fact with their children spending time with me, even solo. I try to be the voice of moderation when such things come up--I don't agree with the idea of not watching any videos, but I also don't say what I'm thinking. I instead, to a child of this age, say, "That's one way of handling it," and then give a brief explanation of my way of handling it. Scary.
And then, I think, gee, in the MO community they /do/ let their children watch videos; and it doesn't seem to prevent them from watching inappropriate movies and shows later on. So maybe encouraging the children to make judgements doesn't work either.
My hope is that the reason those MO children are making what I consider to be poor judgements is that as children they were allowed to watch /any/thing, and never told, "No, Mommy doesn't like that movie. It has things in it Mommy doesn't like to see." So that the right-wing kids never learn judement in the never-seeing-anything way, and the MO kids never learn judgement in the allowed-to-see-anything way.
I cling to this hope, and hope that if I teach my child that some things are fine, and good, and valuable, and some are not, he will learn to make judgements. |
|
|